Rina Bhattacharya and Hirut Wolde of the IMF have
analyzed MENA foreign trade and come to the conclusion that trade is some 86% below what would be expected given the characteristics of these countries' economies. The non-oil exports of the MENA countries are significantly lower as a share of GDP compared to all other developing regions of the world. Imports are also lower as a share of GDP compared to the same regions, with the exception of sub-Saharan Africa. This is documented in Figures 1-6 of the study.
The conclusion is that two factors are primarily responsible for trade under performance:
- Transportation problems
- Customs clearance "inefficiencies"
While one might quibble about just how precise the conclusions are (Is it really 86%? Or is it 83%?), the bigger picture of under performance is less subject to debate.
And that really is the central message from the study - quite a disturbing one for an area facing a demographic "explosion" and the need to create new jobs.